In the published research formulation used in this article, about 71% of the weight is solid particles and about 29% is fat. Because solids are denser than fat, that puts the solids at roughly 60% of the volume, close to the limit at which a suspension stops flowing. (These figures are estimates from stated assumptions, not plant data.) Yet the product has to spread like a fluid and stay in one piece for months.
A chocolate-hazelnut spread may look like a relatively simple product. It contains ingredients such as roasted hazelnuts, cocoa powder, sugar, milk solids, vegetable fats and emulsifiers. Yet manufacturing a product that remains smooth, spreadable and physically stable throughout its shelf life requires careful control of several interacting variables.

Unlike conventional chocolate, which is primarily structured around cocoa butter, a chocolate-hazelnut spread is generally an anhydrous, fat-continuous suspension. Fine solid particles are dispersed throughout a continuous fat phase. The product must have enough structure to resist oil separation during storage, but it must also flow sufficiently when a consumer spreads it.
Achieving this balance is the central engineering challenge.
Understanding the Product Structure
The first important consideration is that the product is more than a mixture of chocolate and nut paste.
Its solid phase may contain sugar, cocoa particles, milk solids and hazelnut solids. The continuous phase consists of liquid and, depending on the fat system and temperature, partially crystalline fats. Figure 1 shows the picture: solid particles of different kinds held in liquid oil, with a network of small fat crystals that gives the product its body.

Figure 1. A fat-continuous suspension: dispersed solids in liquid oil, structured by fat crystals (schematic)
Each component contributes differently:
- Sugar provides sweetness and contributes significantly to the solid particle loading.
- Cocoa powder contributes colour, flavour and additional dispersed solids.
- Hazelnut paste contributes nut solids and natural oil.
- Milk solids influence flavour, texture and the composition of the dispersed phase.
- Vegetable fats help establish the continuous phase and influence consistency, melting behaviour and storage stability.
- Emulsifiers and structuring agents influence particle-fat interactions, flow and resistance to oil separation.
The final behaviour depends not only on the percentage of each ingredient but also on how these ingredients are incorporated and processed.
Figure 2 shows one published research formulation, with sugar at 43%, added palm oil at 19.5%, hazelnut paste at 14.6%, skimmed milk powder at 13.1%, cocoa powder at 6%, whey powder at 3% and soy lecithin at 0.7%. It is a laboratory recipe from the literature, and it is not a commercial formulation.

Figure 2. A published research formulation for a cocoa-hazelnut spread (Marra et al., 2023)
Why the solids volume fraction matters
Formulations are written by weight, but flow is governed by volume. Hazelnut paste is roughly 60% oil, so the nut paste contributes fat as well as solids. Adding the nut oil and the small fat contributions from cocoa and milk powder to the added palm oil gives total fat of about 29% by weight. With fat at a density near 0.92 g/cm³ and the solids near 1.5 g/cm³, that is about 40% fat and 60% solids by volume.
At such loadings, viscosity climbs steeply. The Krieger-Dougherty relationship, a standard model for suspensions, shows relative viscosity rising towards infinity as the solids fraction approaches the maximum packing fraction. A narrow particle-size distribution packs to roughly 0.64, and a broad one packs closer to 0.74, because small particles fit in the gaps between large ones. In the model of Figure 3, a broad distribution at 0.50 solids has a relative viscosity of about 8, rising to about 22 at 0.60. A narrow distribution goes from about 11 to about 84 over the same range.

Figure 3. Relative viscosity against solids volume fraction for two packing limits (illustrative model).
This is why a small change in fat content, or in the shape of the particle-size distribution, can change flow far more than the recipe change alone would suggest.
Related Reading:- We don’t really manufacture chocolate, we manufacture its structure
Fat Phase Preparation and Powder Dispersion
The manufacturing process commonly begins by preparing a homogeneous fat phase. Hazelnut paste and the selected vegetable fat are blended under controlled temperature conditions to obtain a consistent liquid medium. Figure 4 shows the sequence and the variable that most needs control at each stage.

Figure 4. Process sequence for a chocolate-hazelnut spread, with the key control variable at each stage.
The dry ingredients are then incorporated into this phase.
This stage is more important than it may appear. Powder addition introduces a large surface area that must be wetted and dispersed by the available fat. If powder is introduced too quickly, or if the mixing system cannot distribute it effectively, agglomerates can form.
These agglomerates may survive subsequent processing and create local variations in texture and consistency. An agglomerate that reaches the refiner behaves like one large particle with fat and air trapped inside it. That removes fat from the continuous phase and adds to the apparent solids, so it raises viscosity while contributing nothing to smoothness.
The available fat must therefore be sufficient to support effective dispersion of the solid particles, which takes more than making the mixture look wet. Moisture belongs in this discussion as well. The product is anhydrous, and water from nuts, cocoa, milk powder or humid air bonds to sugar surfaces and promotes particle-to-particle sticking, so moisture is one more variable that raises apparent viscosity.
Refining: Particle Size and Fat Demand
Refining reduces particle size and improves the smoothness of the finished product. However, particle-size reduction also changes the total surface area of the dispersed solids.
As particle size decreases, more surface area becomes available for interaction with the continuous fat phase. For roughly spherical particles, specific surface area scales with the inverse of diameter, so reducing the mean size from 30 to 5 microns multiplies the surface by six. This can increase the amount of fat required to maintain a particular flow behaviour.
A simple model shows the mechanism. Suppose each particle carries a thin layer of immobilised fat, which cannot act as free lubricant. The layer is a negligible share of the volume of a coarse particle but a significant share of a fine one, so the effective solids fraction rises as particles shrink. With a 0.1 micron layer, a solids fraction of 0.52 and a broad distribution, relative viscosity rises by about 5% when the mean size falls from 30 to 20 microns, by about 22% at 10 microns and by about 75% at 5 microns, as Figure 5 shows.

Figure 5. Surface area and relative viscosity as mean particle size falls at constant recipe (illustrative model)
Consequently, a finer product does not automatically become more fluid.
If the formulation does not provide sufficient available fat, refining may produce a spread with higher resistance to flow, even though its particle size has improved.
There is a second subtlety. Smoothness on the palate is judged from the coarse end of the distribution, for example the d90 or the largest particles. Viscosity is driven largely by the fine end, because that is where the surface area sits. The two targets pull against each other, which is why the whole distribution matters and a single mean size is a poor control point.
The refining equipment, operating intensity, product temperature and residence time must therefore be considered together. The aim is the required texture at the coarse end of the distribution, with the fine end kept in check so the product does not develop excessive resistance to flow. Refining heat also softens the fat, so viscosity readings should always be taken at a fixed, recorded temperature.
Related Reading :- The importance of Micron size in chocolates part 2
Rheology: Balancing Spreadability and Stability
A chocolate-hazelnut spread must satisfy two seemingly opposing requirements.
During use, it should spread easily under applied force. During storage, it should retain sufficient structure to prevent excessive movement of oil and solid particles.
Its behaviour is therefore better understood through rheology than through a single viscosity reading.
Consistency, yield behaviour, shear-thinning characteristics and viscoelastic structure all influence how the product behaves during pumping, filling, storage and application.
Shear rate is the missing variable
A spread experiences very different shear rates in different situations. Slow oil drainage and sagging under gravity involve extremely low shear rates, pumping and filling involve moderate ones, and spreading with a knife involves much higher ones. A product that is shear-thinning with a yield stress can be very stiff at rest and fluid in use, which is exactly the behaviour wanted.

Figure 6. Apparent viscosity against shear rate for a cooler and a warmer product, with indicative process bands (illustrative)
Figure 6 shows the idea. The same product has a very high apparent viscosity in the slow-drainage band and a far lower one in the spreading band. Measuring a single viscosity at one speed samples one point on that curve and tells us nothing about the rest, so a flow curve across the relevant shear-rate range is the more useful test.
Temperature and solid fat content
Temperature is another important variable. Increasing temperature generally increases fluidity as the fat phase becomes less structured. However, the effect depends on the fat composition and its solid-fat content at the operating temperature.
Figure 7 compares two schematic fat blends. The harder blend keeps a high solid fat content at ambient storage temperature, which builds the crystal network that binds oil, and it loses most of that structure by the warm filling range. The softer blend carries much less solid fat at every temperature.

Figure 7. Solid fat content against temperature for a harder and a softer fat blend (schematic).
A formulation that fills easily at elevated temperature may become excessively firm after cooling. Conversely, a product with insufficient structure may remain too fluid and become susceptible to oil migration.
The crystal form matters too. Palm-based fat systems are commonly valued because they tend to crystallise as fine β′ crystals, which build a dense network and a smooth texture. Hazelnut oil, by contrast, is liquid at room temperature and rich in unsaturated fatty acids, so a higher share of nut paste brings more free oil and a softer system that needs more structure from the fat blend.
Emulsifiers and Oil Separation
Emulsifiers are frequently used to modify flow behaviour and improve product consistency. However, their functions should not be treated as interchangeable.
A 2024 study in the Journal of Food Science compared lecithin, ammonium phosphatide (AMP), glycerol monostearate (GMS) and a commercial oil-binding blend in cocoa-hazelnut spreads (Icyer et al., 2024). Each was tested at 0.3, 0.4 and 0.5%, with hardness followed at 15-day intervals for 60 days. Lecithin and AMP gave lower hardness and viscosity, a more fluent consistency and better spreadability. The oil-binding blend and GMS protected stability better. Lecithin held its hardness better than the others during the 60-day storage.
Reported tendencies in a published comparison of emulsifiers in cocoa-hazelnut spread (Icyer et al., 2024). Qualitative summary.
| Emulsifier | Flow and spreadability | Stability against separation |
| Lecithin | Lower hardness and viscosity, better spreadability | Held hardness best over 60 days of storage |
| AMP | Lower hardness and viscosity, better spreadability | Less protective than the oil-binding blend and GMS |
| GMS | Less effective at lowering yield value and plastic viscosity | Protected stability better than the flow-modifying emulsifiers |
| Commercial oil-binding blend | Less fluent than lecithin and AMP | Protected stability better than the flow-modifying emulsifiers |
The pattern is instructive. The emulsifiers that improved flow were not the ones that best protected against separation. Some work by coating sugar surfaces so that particles slide past each other, and others work by strengthening the structure that holds oil. They do different jobs, and a formulation often needs to decide which job matters more and whether a combination serves both. The results demonstrate why emulsifier selection and dosage must be evaluated in the context of the complete formulation.
Oil separation is particularly important. When the fat phase becomes too mobile relative to the surrounding particle structure, oil can migrate and accumulate at the surface.
It is worth being precise about the mechanism. A particle held in a yield-stress fluid stays suspended when the yield stress exceeds roughly 0.1 to 0.2 times g × Δρ × d. For a 20 micron particle with a density difference of about 580 kg/m³ against the oil, that is about 0.02 Pa, a tiny fraction of the yield stress of a structured spread. Simple settling of particles is therefore unlikely to be the main driver. Oil separation is commonly described as drainage of oil through a compressible network of particles and crystals, driven slowly by gravity and speeded by temperature cycling that softens and re-forms the crystal structure.

Figure 8. Factors that decide oil mobility in a spread and the two outcomes
This is not necessarily corrected by adding more emulsifier. Fat composition, solid-fat content, particle-size distribution, refining conditions and the structure developed during processing can all influence oil mobility.
The fat system must therefore be designed to provide the required spreadability while retaining sufficient oil-binding capacity.
Related reading: Emulsifiers: The Sweet Secret to Perfect Chocolate Texture and Emulsifiers in Chocolate Manufacturing Part 2 cover the lecithin optimum and addition sequence
Request an Industrial Audit
If a spread line shows oil separation, grittiness or unstable texture, an audit separates formulation, refining and process causes before another recipe change is tried.
Process Control Beyond the Recipe
A stable chocolate-hazelnut spread cannot be developed through formulation adjustments alone.
The manufacturing process must control:
- Hazelnut roasting and the consistency of the incoming nut material.
- Fat-phase preparation and temperature.
- Powder addition and dispersion.
- Refining intensity and final particle-size distribution.
- Emulsifier type, dosage and addition sequence.
- Final product temperature and filling conditions.
Control points, why they matter and a practical check.
| Stage | Why it matters | Practical check |
| Nut roasting and intake | Roast level and nut quality change flavour and the oil and moisture brought into the mix | Incoming specification, moisture and roast colour on every lot |
| Fat-phase blending | A non-homogeneous fat phase gives local differences in structure | Temperature log and visual check for separation before powder addition |
| Powder addition | Fast addition forms agglomerates that survive downstream | Fixed addition rate, mixing time and a sieve or grind-gauge check |
| Refining | Sets the particle-size distribution and the fat demand | Laser diffraction for the full distribution, with viscosity at a fixed temperature |
| Emulsifier addition | Wrong type, dose or timing changes flow or oil binding | Dosing records and a flow curve before and after addition |
| Cooling and filling | Temperature history decides the crystal structure that forms | Fill temperature, cooling profile and a texture check on filled product |
| Storage | Structure weaknesses show up with time and temperature cycling | Retained samples at set intervals, with accelerated oil separation tests |
The finished product should be evaluated not only immediately after manufacturing but also after storage. Measurements of particle size, rheology, texture and accelerated oil separation can help identify weaknesses that may not be visible during production. A storage programme with checks at fixed intervals, for example every 15 days up to 60 days, gives trend data on hardness and oil release instead of a single pass or fail.
When a defect does appear, a structured sequence saves time, as Figure 9 shows. Start from the symptom, work through formulation and dosing, moisture, particle size and the fat system, and consider emulsifier changes last.

Figure 9. Troubleshooting map for four common defects in a chocolate-hazelnut spread.
Final Thoughts
Manufacturing a chocolate-hazelnut spread is an exercise in controlling a complex fat-continuous suspension.
The challenge is to establish the right relationship between particle size, fat availability, rheological behaviour and structural stability.
A product that looks smooth at the discharge of a refiner is not necessarily a stable product. Its behaviour during cooling, filling, storage and temperature variation must also be considered.
The objective of the process is a smooth chocolate nut paste that retains its intended texture, spreadability and physical stability throughout its shelf life.
Work with Rudvik Engineers
Request an Industrial Audit
Planning a nut paste or spread line, or fixing one that drifts? An Industrial Audit traces defects to the formulation, the refining or the process control, and puts the evidence on paper.
Book a Technical Discovery Session
Questions about nut paste formulation, refining or stability? Book a 45-minute Google Meet session to talk through your product, your equipment and your questions.
A note on evidence: the model curves and bar charts in this article (Figures 3, 5 and 6), the solid fat profiles in Figure 7 and the schematics are illustrations of mechanisms. They are not measurements from a plant or a product. Replace them with your own data before using any number as a target.
